Will Coutinho, the costly Barcelona misfit, show his worth at Aston Villa? | Transfer window


The most important objectives Philippe Coutinho scored as a Barcelona participant have been towards them, which just about sums it up. On mortgage at Bayern Munich, the place he had his most profitable season since leaving Liverpool for €160m, he obtained two in the 8-2 humiliation of the membership that owned him then and regardless of all their efforts to the opposite nonetheless personal him now. That night time in August 2020 he raised a hand to apologise for what he had carried out. Seventeen months later, he has left once more. As for what he has carried out, most supporters would say: “Nothing a lot.”

The one factor anybody in Catalonia regrets about Coutinho’s departure to Aston Villa this week is that it took too lengthy. Really, that’s not solely true: additionally they remorse that there might be no return, besides his. At the finish of the season, he’ll in all probability be again. At which level, they’ll attempt to get him to go away once more. It was laborious sufficient to deliver him in; it proved equally laborious to maneuver him out. He has gone solely on mortgage, Villa – who’re at house to Manchester United on Saturday – paying 65% of his wage, however at least he has gone. The most costly signing in Barcelona’s historical past might have been the worst.

All of which could sound unfair, even merciless. And it in all probability is: there was one thing uncomfortable in watching the therapy of him at instances, in that glimpse of vulnerability and rejection; in the feeling that whereas there’s definitely culpability, circumstance, tradition and context conspired towards him; in watching the good moments slip from view, misplaced to some collective amnesia. As a result of there have been objectives for Barcelona too: 26 of them plus 14 assists in 106 video games isn’t a horrible return.

He scored the opener in a clásico, setting Barcelona on target for a 5-1 demolition of Madrid. He scored in a Copa del Rey semi-final and offered a objective and an help in the last, serving to them full a double in his first season. He was not taking part in once they collapsed and have been knocked out the Champions League in Rome, so that might hardly be held towards him. Had he been there, who is aware of, perhaps they might have received a treble. Which he did with Bayern. There was one thing about him scoring in Lisbon that expressed that the mess isn’t of his making.

And but these two Bayern objectives might be the most telling picture of his time as a Barcelona participant, exactly as a result of they have been symbolic of how damaging the entire factor has been: self-inflicted, actually and metaphorically an personal objective. A portrait of the regime of the former president Josep Maria Bartomeu, a metaphor for the entire disaster and the way they obtained right into a scenario like this. None of the objectives Coutinho scored for Barcelona, forgotten too quick, go away an impression as lasting. Which can be unfair, however a type of melancholy clings to his story, to him.

Philippe Coutinho reacts during Barcelona’s Champions League game at home to Dynamo Kyiv this season.
Philippe Coutinho reacts throughout Barcelona’s Champions League recreation at house to Dynamo Kyiv this season. {Photograph}: High quality Sport Photos/Getty Photos

This ending, which can not even be the finish, expresses it. Barcelona have been so determined to signal Coutinho that having did not get him in the summer time of 2017 they got here again once more at Christmas, and for a mixed value with Ousmane Dembélé that the membership’s finance director had stated could be “irresponsible”, a sackable offence. Their most costly participant leaves for nothing, and even managing that ended up feeling like an achievement. Above all, it was a necessity.

When Coutinho signed Barcelona made a lot of how he had made a “monetary effort” to return, which is what golf equipment too usually say and which proved ironic. Tied to a wage of about €15m a yr after tax, for the previous three years they’ve been as determined to present him away, however the identical wage that made transferring him on so necessary, pushing him in direction of the door earlier than different gamers equally deserving, additionally trapped him.

Everybody knew that that they had overspent when he arrived, which is never a superb begin, however the signing made sense. Xavi Hernández, Barça’s present supervisor, was amongst those that thought his model suitable with the Camp Nou. But when he stated so then, from the outdoors, 4 years on, now inside, he doesn’t solely see it. The sporting director judged him the “supreme substitute” for Andrés Iniesta, which can have been a part of the drawback simply as the worth was. Iniesta’s place was not his, nor precisely was Neymar’s.

Happier times as Philippe Coutinho is presented as a Barcelona player in January 2018.
Happier instances as Philippe Coutinho is offered as a Barcelona participant in January 2018. {Photograph}: Alejandro García/EPA

The technical high quality was there although, as was the bodily capability introduced from England, at least for some time. So too was the welcome – Luis Suárez collected him from the airport – and the first six months have been good, some extent that at this juncture feels worth making in his defence: he obtained 9 objectives and 7 assists in his first 22 video games. But he couldn’t play in Europe and when he arrived Barcelona have been a great distance clear in the league, their success probably not seen as his. By the finish it felt virtually as if he wasn’t actually there. He was hit by harm and, it appeared, insecurity.

Ernesto Valverde needed to discover a place for him, which wasn’t straightforward. There was little level in another person “being Messi” once they had Lionel Messi. Messi and Suárez have been relieved of some duty to press; accommodating one other one wouldn’t work. Makes an attempt to seek out one other position weren’t at all times reciprocated. As an alternative of a willpower to insurgent towards his destiny, combat for that position, there was a touch of inhibition. Coutinho was well-liked and people who educated with him noticed issues – simply not usually on match days. The membership’s tradition didn’t assist both.

The second season began with 4 objectives and an help in the opening 10 league video games, together with that strike towards Madrid, with out Messi in the crew. However there was simply one in every of every in his subsequent 26 La Liga appearances. Frustration grew amongst followers; whistles adopted to which he was not impervious. When he scored towards Manchester United in the Champions League quarter-final, he put his fingers in his ears, vulnerability revealed. Which in fact made it worse.

Suárez stated, tellingly: “The smallest factor you do – tiny, like Philippe did – is made greater. The supervisor stated it: ‘I’m shocked you’re speaking about the gesture and never the nice objective he scored,’ a objective that will have given him confidence. Generally it’s a must to perceive him. If followers desire a participant to carry out, help him, as a result of a participant out on the pitch isn’t silly. He hears it when he loses a ball and there’s this ‘zzzzzhhhhhiiii’.”

The next season Coutinho was in Munich, the first rejection however perhaps an opportunity for a return when Bayern determined to not train their proper to purchase, itself a touch upon confidence in him. Gross sales have been sought however not discovered, so he was caught.

Philippe Coutinho scores Bayern’s eighth goal and his second against Barcelona in Lisbon in August 2020.
Philippe Coutinho scores Bayern’s eighth objective and his second towards Barcelona in Lisbon in August 2020. {Photograph}: Manu Fernández/AFP/Getty Photos

That stated, if certain by circumstance, there was help again at Barcelona. Ronald Koeman, a brand new supervisor, referred to as and stated he needed to play him in his place: as a No 10 behind Messi. There have been two assists and a objective in the opening three league video games. He scored in his first Champions League match too. After which there was … effectively, not a lot, Coutinho fading once more. A meniscus harm meant he didn’t play a recreation after the flip of the yr. He underwent three operations and spent 9 months out.

He was too costly for this, for a membership pressured to lose the greatest participant they’ve had. And, sure, Coutinho nonetheless being there whereas Messi wasn’t performed its half in his public portrayal, nevertheless unjust that was. Once more, they tried to maneuver him on. Once more, they failed. He talked about working to make folks look upon him with “different eyes”. Messi’s departure supplied alternative too. Requested about Coutinho after a powerful show early this season, Koeman replied: “He’s a superb footballer. It’s my job to get the greatest out of them and that begins with placing them of their place.”

The Fiver: join and get our every day soccer e-mail.

“I’ve at all times believed in Coutinho,” Koeman had insisted however others didn’t – and, it generally felt, which may have included Coutinho himself. When he scored towards Valencia in October, his first objective in a yr, he stated he had a “scar that makes me stronger” and a “want to be the greatest I could be”. However at Barcelona, he by no means actually was. Ten days later, Koeman was gone. Now Coutinho has gone, for a second time. “Since I got here again I by no means had a run of 4 or 5 begins in a row to have the ability to be at my greatest stage,” he stated. Now, he might get them, one other likelihood to have an effect in another person’s shirt.