Ukraine crisis exposes divisions in Berlin – POLITICO

Press play to hearken to this text

BERLIN — Russia’s saber-rattling over Ukraine, and its standoff with the West, are laying naked divisions inside Germany’s new governing coalition, posing an early overseas coverage take a look at for Chancellor Olaf Scholz.


On Tuesday, Overseas Minister Annalena Baerbock, of the Greens, a junior coalition accomplice, will probably be in Moscow to satisfy her Russian counterpart Sergey Lavrov for talks that she hopes will result in a de-escalation of tensions on the Ukrainian border, the place Russia has amassed some 100,000 troops.

A collection of conferences final week between Russia and the U.S. and NATO allies — in addition to members of the Group for Safety and Cooperation in Europe — did not ease the tensions, and Moscow continues to threaten navy motion if the West doesn’t meet its calls for, together with a assure that Ukraine and Georgia won’t ever be part of NATO.

Whereas Baerbock has advocated for each dialogue with and a stricter line towards Russia, her go to to Moscow is difficult by conflicting indicators coming from the chancellor’s Social Democratic Celebration (SPD), and dangers the looks that Berlin could also be partaking in a little bit of freelancing at a time when Western allies have labored laborious to painting themselves as utterly in lockstep on the subject of the Kremlin.

The divisions inside Germany’s coalition are notably seen on the subject of the controversial Nord Stream 2 fuel pipeline, which critics name a “geopolitical weapon” that Moscow might use in opposition to Ukraine or the EU, and which the U.S. has mentioned can be topic to sweeping sanctions in the case of an assault on Ukraine.

Senior SPD politicians have defended Nord Stream 2, together with Protection Minister Christine Lambrecht and the social gathering’s Secretary-Common Kevin Kühnert, who final week mentioned the pipeline shouldn’t be linked in any solution to the Russian-Ukrainian tensions. That raised questions in regards to the seriousness of repeated warnings to Moscow by Germany and the EU that any additional aggression in opposition to Ukraine would have “critical penalties.”

Scholz himself has additionally taken a comfortable line and final month even argued the pipeline was merely a “personal financial system venture,” suggesting it had no political dimension — a view that’s hotly disputed by Kyiv and by jap EU nations, together with Poland and the Baltic states.

Throughout a go to to Madrid on Monday, Scholz dodged a reporter’s query about whether or not he was nonetheless of that opinion and as a substitute mentioned that Moscow would pay “a excessive worth” for attacking Ukraine.

“The scenario could be very critical,” Scholz mentioned. “The motion of [Russian] troops alongside the Ukrainian border can’t be missed. It’s large, and it’s a menace to the sovereignty of Ukraine. And due to this fact all the things should be carried out to forestall a navy escalation.”

The SPD has a protracted historical past of taking a softer line on Russia, notably by way of the Ostpolitik of former Chancellor Willy Brandt, who sought diplomatic engagement with the Soviet Union and communist Japanese European nations in the late Nineteen Sixties and early Nineteen Seventies. Extra lately, one other former SPD chancellor, Gerhard Schröder, has change into a logo of shut financial ties with Moscow, as chairman of the Nord Stream shareholders’ committee.

Some Social Democrats, nevertheless, are actually pushing for a more durable line. “It should be clear to all events that, in the occasion of an additional navy escalation in opposition to Ukraine, we can not merely return to enterprise as standard,” Michael Roth, a former Europe minister and now chair of the Bundestag’s overseas affairs committee, informed POLITICO.

“The EU should put all choices — together with Nord Stream 2 — on the desk. We can not merely stick with it as earlier than,” Roth added. “That is positively not a matter for Germany alone; it should be mentioned in live performance with the EU.”

Arms export conundrum

Germany’s uneven place on Nord Stream appears seemingly so as to add to the challenges dealing with Baerbock as she engages with Lavrov, extensively considered as one of the fearsome diplomats on the world stage.

Forward of her journey to the Russian capital, the overseas minister was already underneath strain throughout a go to on Monday to Ukraine, the place she confronted criticism over Germany’s refusal to permit arms shipments, particularly of air protection weapons, to Kyiv.


Baerbock careworn that she wished “to underline that we do not conduct any talks over Ukraine with out involving Ukraine,” and that Russia had no proper to inform Ukraine to not aspire to membership of NATO, however these remarks weren’t sufficient to assuage the anger.

Over the weekend, Kyiv’s ambassador to Berlin, Andrij Melnyk, mentioned the Ukrainian individuals had been “extraordinarily disenchanted” on the German place, and Ukrainian Overseas Minister Dmytro Kuleba mentioned Monday throughout a information convention with Baerbock that any weapons provided would merely be used to defend Ukrainian territory in opposition to a possible Russian assault.

Baerbock, nevertheless, reiterated Berlin’s refusal to grant the request and careworn that out of “historic accountability,” Germany couldn’t ship any weapons to crisis zones. “The German contribution to supporting Ukraine, to Ukraine’s safety … could be very multifaceted,” she mentioned, arguing her nation was serving to by treating wounded troopers and constructing a navy hospital.

Scholz backed the overseas minister on that time on Monday, mentioning that the earlier conservative-led authorities of Angela Merkel had additionally refused to export arms to Kyiv. “The federal government is performing in a really unified means on this difficulty, and that features being in line with what German governments have carried out correctly on this difficulty in the previous,” he mentioned.

‘Enhancing relations’

For a lot of Western powers, Baerbock’s go to and the German coalition’s unease imply Moscow might see a possibility to sow divisions between Germany, the EU’s largest and richest member, and different NATO allies as they search to keep up unity in the face of Russian threats.

Baerbock’s look in the Russian capital dangers sending a message that Berlin cares extra about its bilateral relations, together with financial ties, than it does in regards to the Russian navy buildup on the border with Ukraine. That troop build-up continues, with reviews on Monday that Russian forces have begun arriving in Belarus for joint navy workouts.

Russia is at all times eager to divide Western allies and on Monday, the Russian Overseas Ministry issued a long statement about Baerbock’s go to that made clear her assembly with Lavrov can be used to painting relations with Germany as robust regardless of the present safety tensions. The ministry was even so daring as to say that “the demand for enhancing relations with Russia is current in German society.”

“Throughout the talks between the ministers, it’s deliberate to debate the state and prospects of Russian-German relations, the formation of a schedule of political contacts, the sensible elements of constructing cooperation in the commerce, financial, cultural, humanitarian and historical-memorial spheres,” the ministry said.

The press launch added, “There will probably be an in-depth alternate of views on probably the most urgent worldwide issues, primarily the implementation of Russian proposals for complete safety ensures in Europe.”

The assertion additionally sought to flatter Berlin, saying Moscow “regards Germany as an influential participant in the worldwide area, a big neighbor for us, with which Russia’s relations have at all times retained a particular character.”

The SPD’s Roth mentioned he hopes Baerbock’s go to will probably be “the prelude to additional talks” to de-escalate the scenario on the Ukrainian border.

However Roth additionally acknowledged that the mission will probably be tough and meant a conflict of “completely different cultures of diplomacy.”

Need extra evaluation from POLITICO? POLITICO Professional is our premium intelligence service for professionals. From monetary companies to commerce, know-how, cybersecurity and extra, Professional delivers actual time intelligence, deep perception and breaking scoops it is advisable to hold one step forward. E mail [email protected] to request a complimentary trial.

Show More

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button