The prospect of Johnson’s downfall is joyful. The threat of what may follow is not | John Harris

For proof of how harmful Boris Johnson’s management has turn into, think about this: public well being coverage is now merely a subplot within the horrendous drama engulfing the Conservative occasion. Over the weekend, as authorities advisers urged warning over Covid restrictions, the prime minister’s allies suggested that the approaching lifting of England’s remaining curbs would launch his fightback. However an unnamed minister cited in the Spectator thought that binning the final guidelines may neatly coincide with the prime minister’s resignation. This, it was mentioned, would give him a chance to say an enormous job had been finished and “depart with dignity”.

However as with most of what we’re listening to from senior Tories, the suggestion appeared to have one other that means: his exit is imagined not simply as the top of Johnson’s time on the prime, however the curtain falling on a interval of interventionist, big-spending authorities, so regular Tory service might be resumed.

Clearly, the prime minister’s shame is solely all the way down to occasions in Downing Road, the dreadful symbolism of so many components of the story, and an administration mired in conceitedness, deceit and an terrible absence of seriousness – a situation now to be cured by a staff-blaming effort which has been named “Operation Save Big Dog”. However within the surrounding temper music, there are additionally ideological components. Over the previous two years, because the Treasury funded folks’s wages, austerity diminished as a political precedence, and the state’s attain elevated to an extent unseen exterior wartime, there was lots of hypothesis about how these modifications would completely alter politics.

For the Tories, such a shift would have gone hand-in-hand with what Johnson embraced, albeit in his typical half-arsed manner: his embryonic “levelling up” drive, a readiness to place up taxes, the flexing of the state’s muscle mass in pursuit of internet zero carbon emissions. However almost two years on from the beginning of the pandemic, with the prime minister seemingly damaged and potential successors on lower than delicate manoeuvres, Conservatism does not really feel like that in any respect.


Fairly than pushing their politics someplace new, the Covid disaster appears to have despatched terrified Tories again to their previous beliefs – in small authorities, untrammelled enterprise and the concept that even well-intentioned spending all the time results in catastrophe. Again in December, when the federal government confronted an enormous parliamentary revolt over new restrictions, Westminster journalists had been picking up anxiety amongst Conservative MPs a couple of “Covid state”, and the danger of Johnson making a “high-tax, high-spending, high-inflation nation”. Steve Baker, the de facto chief of the Brexit backbench hardcore, thinks that “at the moment’s Conservative occasion is within the improper place and heading in the wrong way of Conservatism”. In the meantime, rightwing columnists rage at a authorities supposedly waging struggle “on automobiles, international journey and all different components of the suburban dream”.

As ever, a dependable indicator of Tory restlessness is how typically folks point out Margaret Thatcher. Baker has simply relaunched the self-consciously Thatcherite stress group Conservative Method Ahead. In the meantime, the frontrunners for Johnson’s job are routinely seen as inheritors of her mantle. In accordance with the Economist, Rishi Sunak “has the identical ingrained enthusiasm for balancing budgets and limiting expenditure as the grocery store’s daughter had”. Liz Truss appears ecstatically joyful to provide the impression of somebody starring in a faculty play concerning the blessed Margaret, and makes speeches concerning the risks of “inexorably rising the dimensions of the state”, versus the wonders of “free commerce and free enterprise”.

Chancellor Rishi Sunak and foreign secretary Liz Truss during prime minister’s questions, October 2021.
Chancellor Rishi Sunak and international secretary Liz Truss throughout prime minister’s questions, October 2021. {Photograph}: UK Parliament/Jessica Taylor/PA

A lot the identical instincts outline potential candidates corresponding to Kwasi Kwarteng, Nadhim Zahawi and Priti Patel. If Johnson’s extra interventionist Toryism has any base of assist, it in all probability lies among the many new MPs elected within the so-called pink wall seats, however they’re too marginal and inexperienced to discipline a candidate, or exert a lot affect. So, when his fall comes, it appears to be like set to herald a second of ideological restoration. Johnson’s reckless authoritarianism – the one facet of his file that does echo Thatcher – will presumably be retained; what shall be thrown overboard would be the final significant traces of levelling up, and any pretence that Conservatism is keen on altering the financial system for the great of society.

Is that this what 2022 actually calls for? Thatcherism may nonetheless outline the Tory soul, the nation it was designed to vary has lengthy gone due to Conservative victories within the Eighties. The revolution was not left half-finished however accomplished: there are not any highly effective unions to tame, no utilities to privatise, no huge bang to detonate within the Metropolis, and not a lot else to decontrol. Some Conservatives wish to lastly topic the NHS to the disciplines of revenue and loss, however to take action would threat political calamity. The resumed chopping of public spending may gladden Thatcherite hearts, however extra smart Tories way back realised that austerity had already gone manner too far.

The purpose that there have been sporadic Tory makes an attempt to maneuver away from the politics of the free market – the fitful stirrings of “pink Toryism”, the tilts in that route below each Johnson and Theresa May – is as a result of that strategy has lengthy since run out of highway. Actually, if whoever succeeds Johnson needs to maintain the electoral coalition that delivered victory two years in the past, the necessity for various considering ought to be apparent.

But the self-styled inheritors of Thatcherism have all the time wished to maintain the revolution going, and their livid zeal has lengthy since turned Conservative politics unhinged and unusual. Within the absence of an enormous, disruptive Thatcher-esque venture, Brexit – together with the insane concept of turning the UK financial system into “Singapore-on-Thames” – moved from the political fringes to the Tory mainstream and unsettled the occasion’s relationship with many of its previous suburban heartlands, that are not simply full of remainers however more and more liberal and left-leaning.

Within the beliefs of Truss, Kwarteng, Patel and extra, you see Thatcherism taken to its logical conclusion, as a chilly credo that wishes to utterly subjugate life to the calls for of the market. (Keep in mind that infamous sentence of their ebook Britannia Unchained: “As soon as they enter the office, the British are among the many worst idlers on the earth.”) Within the arms of Baker and co, Thatcher’s legacy has ceased to be about concepts and coverage, however has been decreased as a substitute to a puritanical animus that leads folks to endlessly scent betrayal and plot towards the folks on the prime. The Tories may quickly be on to their seventh chief in 20 years. This, maybe, is what occurs when a celebration merely doesn’t know what to do with itself.

Amongst folks on the left, there is a righteous relish concerning the prospect of Johnson’s departure, and with superb purpose. However this ought to be seen as an uneasy second, replete with each hope and hazard. Even when he goes, it might be almost two-and a half years till one other common election. Any Conservative voices who may warn towards their occasion’s resurgent proper are thus far conspicuously quiet. If the subsequent occupant of Downing Road makes an attempt the full-blown return of Tory concepts which have already torn Britain aside, may the weary public temper after Brexit and Covid enable them to succeed? Or will one thing so clearly out of step with its time quickly fail? Each time post-Johnson politics arrives, these shall be its defining questions.

Show More

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button