The 240-page petition, “We Charge Genocide: The Crime of Government Against the Negro People,” was meant to be sensational. America had been instrumental in prosecuting the Nazis at Nuremberg, and now its personal residents have been turning the lens again on the U.S. in the most horrifying, accusatory phrases.
As an alternative, mainstream media largely ignored it. The New York Instances and Washington Put up talked about the petition in short tales buried in the again pages. The Chicago Tribune condemned it for “shameful lies.” Raphael Lemkin, the Polish jurist who had coined the time period “genocide,” publicly disagreed with the entire foundation of the petition, saying it confused genocide with discrimination.
The drafters of the doc hadn’t anticipated it to go wherever; they knew the U.S. had an excessive amount of energy at the U.N. for the petition to be taken up. They had written it much less as a proper cost than as a presentation of an allegation, loosely written in the mannequin of a authorized transient. They hoped, although didn’t count on, that the Normal Meeting, Fee on Human Rights or one other occasion at the U.N. may take up the difficulty for deliberation. That by no means occurred.
However in the present day, 70 years later, the doc has a brand new resonance amid the patent injustices of police brutality that proceed to happen and racial inequities in well being care on show particularly all through the pandemic. “We Cost Genocide” explored these varieties of points at size, making a compelling case for fascinated with structural racism as genocide, which calls for not solely condemnation but additionally redress and restore. To think about the arguments in “We Cost Genocide,” drafted by some of the most notable figures in the midcentury civil rights motion, gives essential insights into the present second and transfer ahead.
Two occasions set the stage for the Black genocide cost in 1951 — one worldwide, and one home.
The primary was near a miracle. After two years of political haggling following Nazi atrocities, U.N. member states every agreed to relinquish a small piece of their sacrosanct sovereignty when the physique handed the 1948 Conference on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. This codified a authorized definition of genocide, criminalizing group destruction and opening the door to strive perpetrators in a world courtroom of legislation. Since then, the conference has been used each to carry perpetrators of genocide accountable in locations like Rwanda, the former Yugoslavia and Cambodia and, importantly, to arrange or pave the approach for remediation mechanisms after it’s been established that genocide occurred.
The Conference defined genocide as “acts dedicated with the intent to destroy, in entire or partially, a nationwide, ethnical, racial or non secular group, as such.” It additionally specified that these acts embody not simply killing but additionally tried group destruction by way of “bodily or psychological hurt,” impeding copy, harsh residing situations and youngster elimination.
Second, the Black civil rights motion gained momentum after World Warfare II. Freedom struggles and racism turned a spotlight of worldwide consideration, and the newly established U.N., which included a Fee on Human Rights, supplied a brand new, world platform for protest in opposition to racism in the U.S. Black activists used it to internationalize and broaden their motion, partially by reframing it in phrases of human rights.
Two prior petitions preceded “We Cost Genocide.” In 1946, the Nationwide Negro Congress delivered an eight-page petition to the U.N. Secretary-Normal asking him to take motion on the subjugation of Black People, notably in the South, the place 10 million Black folks lived in deplorable situations. The U.N., mired in politics, didn’t act. However the petition had some success, notably overseas, in drawing consideration to the plight of Black People.
Seeing the potential of such petitions, the NAACP, pissed off by the U.S. authorities’s gradual tempo of racial reform, undertook a way more bold initiative. On Oct. 23, 1947, it offered an intensive, 95-page “Attraction to the World!” petition to the U.N. The assertion, which garnered rather more consideration, lambasted the U.S. for denying a bunch of human rights to its Black minority inhabitants.
“We Cost Genocide,” a undertaking of the Civil Rights Congress, adopted on this custom, but it surely was much more bold and inflammatory, explicitly situating its documentation of U.S. racism inside the framework of genocide — a brand new sort of crime, freshly outlined by the U.N.
“We Cost Genocide” begins with killing: The petition documents hundreds of killings and different abuses, some involving police, which befell from 1945, when the U.N. was established, to 1951. It asserts that greater than 10,000 Black folks had been lynched or killed, typically for one thing as small as “failure to say ‘sir’ or tip their hats.” Many extra, it provides, suffered from “severe bodily and psychological hurt” from beatings, assaults and the terror brought on by the fixed risk of such assaults.
Direct violence was just one half of the cost. One other half was the systematic remedy of Black folks inside society. The petitioners have been taking the minimalist language of the U.N. conference on genocide, about issues like situations of life, and giving it form and type with real-world examples. The petition define the harsh residing situations to which Black People have been topic: lives diminished in phrases of housing, medical care, schooling, segregation, job alternatives, sharecropping, incarceration, housing, poverty and voter suppression. Because of this, the petition states, 30,000 additional Black folks have been dying every year, and Black People have been residing eight years lower than white folks. Officers from all three branches of the U.S. authorities, the petition alleges, have been responsible of inciting, conspiring to commit or being complicit in such genocidal acts, with examples starting from police violence to racist legal guidelines promulgated by members of Congress.
Proof of Black genocide, the petition concludes, “is all over the place in American life,” and as “the conscience of mankind,” the U.N. Normal Meeting shouldn’t stand by silently however ought to as a substitute each condemn the U.S. and demand that the nation take steps to cease the genocide and forestall its persistence.
The petition had 94 signatories, together with household of victims. Some have been with Robeson when he offered the petition to the U.N. in New York, together with the widow of one of the “Martinsville Seven,” executed after being falsely accused of raping a white girl.
The petition was acquired by U.N. officers in Paris and New York. Patterson even mentioned it with a handful of delegates from nations like Egypt, Ethiopia, Haiti, India and Liberia. However nobody agreed to take it ahead.
Chilly Warfare politics have been a big half of the motive why. The U.S. authorities — frightened about dangerous PR throughout the Chilly Warfare — mounted a marketing campaign to blunt any home and worldwide influence it may need.
In 1951, the Purple Scare was in full swing. The Soviet Union was nuclear; Mao had taken over China; battle was raging in Korea; and Senator Joseph McCarthy was main now-infamous hearings on the communist infiltration of U.S. Black nationalists. “We Cost Genocide” petitioners have been amongst the targets. The federal government had already confiscated Robeson’s passport, which is why he offered the doc in New York. It seized Patterson’s after he offered the petition in Paris.