Mung beans, bunnies and the Muppets: PM’s green rhetoric ‘insulting and divisive’ | Cop26

Boris Johnson took the stage at Glasgow as the Cop26 summit neared its conclusion final Wednesday, aiming to galvanise the convention right into a deal that might stave off local weather breakdown.

As an alternative, confronting the world’s media instantly afterwards, he confronted a barrage of questions on Tory sleaze, the international issues of the local weather disaster eclipsed by a sordid Westminster scandal.

Whilst the prime minister was compelled to disclaim that the UK was a corrupt nation, unknown to him or his closest aides, the actual worldwide statesmanship was happening in windowless rooms barely 100 metres away in the windswept convention centre.

John Kerry, the US local weather envoy, and Xie Zhenhua, China’s head of delegation, have been placing the ending touches to a press release by the world’s two superpowers that might set the tone for a Glasgow local weather deal.

Xie and Kerry laid out the particulars of their pact on Wednesday night in the similar press convention room the place Johnson had sweated below shut questioning somewhat over an hour beforehand. Downing Road was blindsided, having performed no half in the announcement, hailed as “game-changing” by observers.

For a few of these following the talks, it was simply the newest in a protracted sequence of prime ministerial misses, absences and gaffes. Most of the previous yr has been marked by Johnson’s lengthy silences on local weather points, punctuated by just a few set-piece events.

“Johnson has been largely a bystander,” says Tom Burke, veteran local weather adviser to governments and co-founder of the E3G green thinktank. “He has not imposed his stamp on this subject. He has not put in the hours. He has not been spending the time he wanted to, assembly his friends in different nations, which it’s important to so that you simply construct up these key relationships.”

Johnson chaired no conferences on the local weather at the same time as the UK was making ready to host the talks, from the finish of the earlier Cop in Madrid in 2019 to the launch of the UK’s presidency in February 2020. He participated in a joint UK-UN-French celebration of the five-year anniversary of the Paris settlement in December 2020, then was largely silent for months till a White Home local weather summit in April.

After that, whereas the UK cupboard minister and Cop26 president Alok Sharma carried out a busy spherical of diplomacy from 9 Downing Road, virtually nothing was heard on the local weather from No 10 till Johnson hosted the G7 in Cornwall in July, a gathering dominated by rows over Brexit and sausages.

Boris Johnson leaves the stage after delivering a speech during the opening ceremony of Cop26.
Boris Johnson leaves the stage after delivering a speech throughout the opening ceremony of Cop26. {Photograph}: Yves Herman/Reuters

Alongside the means, there have been scandals that angered green consultants way over any rows over MPs’ second jobs. The protracted determination, nonetheless ongoing, over a possible new coalmine in Cumbria outraged local weather scientists early this yr; new licences for oil and gasfields in the North Sea gave a poor sign to different nations, no matter the authorities mentioned about permitting them provided that there was a “local weather check”; the determination to slash abroad support seemed ill-judged, coming as the UK was exhorting different nations to supply billions to creating nations in local weather finance.

Downing Road appeared to not realise how damaging these gaffes have been. “Johnson was not paying sufficient consideration,” says Burke.

Seen from overseas, the UK has carried out properly on the organisational points of Cop26 and on local weather diplomacy, however Johnson himself has been a puzzle.

His rhetorical flights of fancy involving “mung-bean munching” and “bunny-hugging” – references to the supposed actions of environmentalists – have been judged “divisive and insulting” by green consultants in the UK, whereas many exterior the nation struggled to comply with. “It’s simple to be green,” he advised the UN normal meeting, a Muppets quip that left his fellow world leaders nonplussed.

“The messaging was complicated – mung beans, Kermit the Frog, that this was an atmosphere agenda fairly than a [global] security and well being and survival agenda,” says Rachel Kyte, previously a high local weather official at the World Financial institution, now dean of the Fletcher Faculty at Tufts College in the US. “Saying he gave [Cop26] a six out of 10 probability of success as he arrived at the UN normal meeting was odd.”

Paul Bledsoe, a former Clinton-era White Home local weather adviser, now with the Progressive Coverage Institute thinktank in Washington DC, says the UK carried out properly logistically and diplomatically, however that Johnson’s position was at all times going to be restricted by the realities of geopolitics.

“Realistically, Johnson himself was by no means going to be the key negotiator or creator of revolutionary diplomatic or technical breakthroughs. The US, China, India, Brazil, Russia, Indonesia, Saudi Arabia and just a few others – these are the nations the place coverage positions have performed the largest roles, as traditional.”

However he provides Johnson credit score for being a Conservative politician who has seen the significance of the local weather agenda when some on the proper have sought to disclaim or obfuscate it.

“Johnson’s real local weather advocacy as a pacesetter of a centre-right political get together has been essential to setting an environment of ambition on urgency. The query is, will he proceed to push China, Russia and different local weather laggards, and additionally double down on UK home commitments after the tv crews have left Glasgow?”

Though Cop26 has ended, below the UN guidelines, the UK will stay Cop president for the subsequent yr, till Egypt takes over at Cop27 subsequent autumn. That offers Johnson a yr wherein to press forward with this agenda and safe a worldwide legacy of local weather motion to make sure the end result of the summit is carried by into insurance policies and measures round the world.

Shaun Spiers, of the Green Alliance thinktank, says: “This is a chance to current World Britain to the world. However the final two weeks have proven that local weather diplomacy requires sustained consideration. This should be a complete authorities effort.”

Show More

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button