Lawmakers skewer interim CIA report on Havana Syndrome

“I’m anxious to listen to what CIA’s response goes to be. I’m anxious to listen to different affected departments [too],” Senate Intelligence Committee Chair Mark Warner (D-Va.) mentioned in a quick interview.

Warner revealed that the intelligence group’s professional panel on Havana Syndrome is predicted to wrap up its work “in about 10 days,” and he questioned why the CIA would get forward of that group’s work.

“It may need been higher to have this concurrently launched,” Warner mentioned.


Victims of Havana Syndrome — a bunch that largely consists of American diplomats and intelligence officers — have skilled a variety of debilitating signs together with piercing complications, intense stress and ringing within the ears, and documented traumatic mind accidents that medical specialists have mentioned might be related to pulsed microwave power. Suspected instances have been detected in main cities in Europe, Asia, South America and even in and round Washington, D.C.

The interim evaluation discovered {that a} majority of reported instances might be defined by a wide range of medical, environmental or technical elements, and it was primarily a “narrowing-down” effort by the company. However an intelligence group supply mentioned the report “doesn’t replicate the unanimous consensus of the intelligence group,” and a senior CIA official mentioned there are “various ranges of confidence inside completely different businesses.”

The double-digit variety of unresolved instances continues to stump investigators, who’ve lengthy struggled to grasp the phenomenon because it was first detected amongst U.S. diplomats serving in Havana, Cuba, in 2016.

Officers from throughout the federal government have informed lawmakers repeatedly in categorized briefings over the previous yr that U.S. investigators imagine the incidents, particularly people who have brought about traumatic mind accidents, are the results of directed-energy assaults, more than likely by the hands of a hostile overseas authorities equivalent to Russia.

Whereas the interim CIA report doesn’t utterly undercut that evaluation, it pushes again on the concept that the a whole lot of reported instances can all be attributed to the identical supply. It leaves open the chance {that a} U.S. adversary might be intentionally harming these whose instances haven’t been resolved.

“Every thing we’ve been informed to this point is completely different. Abruptly we give you a unique conclusion?” Senate Overseas Relations Committee Chair Bob Menendez (D-N.J.) mentioned in a quick interview. His panel has jurisdiction over the State Division, the place a lot of the reported instances have originated.

“When you’ve got an inconclusive dedication, which isn’t a dedication, why do you’re feeling compelled to difficulty an interim report that’s inconclusive?” Menendez mentioned. “So the timing, I don’t fairly get it.”

The Senate Intelligence Committee held a “strong session” behind closed doorways on the topic on Wednesday, Warner mentioned, and “I’ve nonetheless obtained questions that should be answered.”

“A few of our working assumptions that we’ve had for a while — am I shocked they didn’t pan out? Sure, however I’ve obtained to additionally go the place the details lie,” he mentioned, including that he has “enormous confidence” in CIA Director William Burns, who has positioned a renewed emphasis on the difficulty.

Susan Buikema-Miller, a CIA spokesperson, mentioned in a press release: “We’re deeply dedicated to the care and wellbeing of our officers and we are going to proceed to analyze this vital matter. We respect our partnership with our intelligence oversight committees.”

Lawmakers’ criticisms align with these publicized by a number of Havana Syndrome victims, who launched a press release Wednesday evening calling the CIA product “a breach of religion, and an undermining of the intent of Congress and the president to face with us and attain a authorities large consensus as to what’s behind this.”

Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine), an Intelligence Committee member who has met with Havana Syndrome victims, mentioned she was “shocked at lots of the findings, which appeared to contradict different testimony that we have now had.” She added that she’s “reassured that the CIA is dedicated to taking good care of folks” who’ve suffered medical issues.


Collins, together with different senators from each events, co-authored laws final yr to help victims with medical prices and different bureaucratic hurdles. The Home and Senate handed the measure unanimously, and President Joe Biden signed it into regulation.

The legislative push got here after POLITICO first reported that the Biden administration was elevating issues to lawmakers in categorized briefings about what officers described because the rising menace to U.S. diplomats and intelligence officers. Within the final yr alone, dozens of suspected Havana Syndrome instances have been reported on practically each continent.

Final yr, lawmakers started referring to the incidents as suspected “directed-energy assaults,” which was according to the briefings being supplied to them by high Biden administration officers.

Sen. Jeanne Shaheen (D-N.H.), who has personally assisted victims by way of her workplace, continued to discuss with the incidents as “suspected directed-energy assaults” in a press release, and mentioned she was “undeterred” in her efforts to help victims.

In statements issued Thursday, senators additionally emphasised that the CIA’s interim evaluation was solely the work of 1 a part of one intelligence company.

“It’s vital to notice that the CIA’s present evaluation on what and who could also be behind [anomalous health incidents] which have affected U.S. intelligence and diplomatic personnel displays solely the interim work of the CIA job power,” Senate Intelligence Committee Vice Chair Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) mentioned. He added that the CIA should proceed its work on whether or not a “core group of instances” resulted from a hostile overseas authorities or a weapon.

And Home Intelligence Committee Chair Adam Schiff (D-Calif.) referred to as the CIA’s findings “a primary step towards answering the numerous questions that we have now about these incidents, however it’s removed from the final.”

Show More

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button