Is TikTok bad? Here’s why many Western countries are taking a closer look

TikTok finds itself underneath elevated scrutiny on each side of the Atlantic Ocean, as Western countries solid a essential eye on the attain the Chinese language-owned platform holds and the dangers which will pose.

Canada’s federal privateness regulator and three provincial counterparts this week launched a joint probe into whether or not the social media platform meets privacy-law expectations and the way it collects and makes use of knowledge. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has individually stated the nation’s digital spy company is looking ahead to threats from TikTok.

A pair of key European Union policy-making institutions additionally banned the video-sharing app from workers telephones over cybersecurity concerns this week. 

Closer to house, a rising record of U.S. states have reportedly banned the app from government phones. There are additionally restrictions in place for U.S. federal authorities staff, with some exceptions.

This intensified deal with all the things TikTok comes amid worsening relations between China and the West, a backdrop that specialists say shouldn’t be ignored.

“There needs to be some acknowledgement of the political local weather in context that we’re debating this [TikTok issue] now,” Vass Bednar, govt director of the Grasp of Public Coverage in Digital Society program at Hamilton’s McMaster College, informed The Canadian Press.

“And I feel asking why now’s an ungainly query as a result of an investigation like this might occur any time and it most likely ought to occur to different firms on social media.”

Canadian considerations

The forthcoming Canadian probe entails the federal privateness commissioner and provincial counterparts in British Columbia, Alberta and Quebec — although the problems are of curiosity nationwide.

“All of Canada’s provincial and territorial privateness commissioners have been notified of the joint investigation,” Vito Pilieci, a senior communications adviser with the Workplace of the Privateness Commissioner of Canada, stated by way of e mail.

WATCH | How frightened do you have to be about TikTok? 

Breaking down TikTok safety considerations

The Nationwide’s Ian Hanomansing asks cyber safety specialists Brian Haugli and Alana Staszcyszyn about how frightened TikTok customers must be about having the app on their gadgets.

Pilieci stated the federal watchdog oversees compliance with Canada’s federal private-sector privateness regulation. However the three provinces have their own such laws which will even be utilized, which is why their regulators are concerned.

After the investigation was introduced, a TikTok spokesperson stated, “We welcome the alternative to work with the federal and provincial privateness safety authorities to set the file straight on how we shield the privateness of Canadians.”

TikTok has been one of many fastest-growing social media platforms within the nation in recent times.

About 26 per cent of adults in Canada are on TikTok, in accordance with a census-balanced online survey taken last spring.That was up from 15 per cent two years earlier.

Seventy-six per cent of Canadian adults aged 18 to 24 had TikTok accounts, in accordance with that very same 2022 survey.

The Canadian regulators’ probe will partly deal with how the platform’s policies affect its youngest users — particularly whether or not TikTok “obtained legitimate and significant consent from these customers for the gathering, use and disclosure of their private info.”

Will customers care?

McMaster College’s Bednar believes the investigation is unlikely to drive Canadians to rethink their use of TikTok.

A visitor takes a photo of a TikTok exhibition at the Gamescom gaming fair in Cologne, Germany, in August 2022.A customer makes a photograph on the TikTok exhibition stands on the Gamescom pc gaming honest in Cologne, Germany, on Aug. 25, 2022. Some specialists doubt whether or not the elevated scrutiny, which incorporates a Canadian probe, will shift shopper considering. (Martin Meissner/The Related Press)

The app is constructed to attract consideration from customers and one which TikTok might know folks are unlikely to desert the platform “which maybe makes the risk [of an investigation] extra empty,” Bednar stated. 

Nevertheless, Sara Grimes, director of the Information Media Design Institute on the College of Toronto, stated the invention of privateness violations or different points may shift shopper considering.

“If the investigation does verify that TikTok is violating our privateness rights, and/or the privateness rights of teenagers and kids, I feel it can undoubtedly sway person habits,” she informed The Canadian Press in an e mail.

“Opposite to well-liked perception, younger folks do care a lot about their privateness and the way their information is used. And oldsters care a lot about their kids’s information too.”

However why TikTok?

Considerations about TikTok aren’t new, and the platform is much like others in many methods. Anatoliy Gruzd, co-director of the Social Media Lab at Toronto Metropolitan College, stated the present ones appear considerably rooted in geopolitical tensions.

A TikTok sticker is seen on the helmet of NHL player Alexander Kerfoot during an October 2021 hockey game.A TikTok sticker is seen on the aspect of Alexander Kerfoot’s helmet throughout an October 2021 NHL sport in Ottawa. (Chris Tanouye/Getty Pictures)

“Like different platforms, TikTok collects person information,” stated Gruzd, noting that unhealthy actors may hack or harass a explicit account as they might elsewhere on social media.

However he stated the “further form of consideration” targeted on TikTok seems linked to its possession by ByteDance, a Chinese language-owned firm and associated considerations its information could possibly be made accessible to Beijing.

Lynette Ong, a political science professor on the College of Toronto, is skeptical that the considerations surrounding TikTok-held information are important when in comparison with different apps — resembling WeChat or Alipay — which will have associated monetary and private information extra worthy of regulatory consideration.

“That’s not to say that Chinese language companies are not able to espionage or posing a risk to our nationwide safety,” she added.

However cybersecurity specialists resembling Brian Haugli, CEO of the U.S. agency SideChannel, who see hazard within the info that TikTok customers could also be unknowingly sharing, after downloading an app that may “see and retailer” a person’s location, the networks they entry and any incoming messages.

“Once you actually form of dig in to all of the permissions that are in there, I do not suppose it is one thing that almost all customers are both conscious of, or prepared to actually hand over, to a firm that is owned and housed within China,” Haugli informed CBC’s The Nationwide in December.

Whereas such considerations have prompted some TikTok bans on EU and U.S. authorities gadgets, it isn’t instantly clear whether or not such a step can be taken right here.

Requested whether or not Canada would observe swimsuit, Treasury Board spokesperson Martin Potvin informed The Canadian Press by e mail that Ottawa “is assessing the state of affairs, together with the legislative announcement by our U.S. allies, and lately the European Fee, and can decide subsequent steps as mandatory.”

Related Articles

Back to top button