How Stu Macher – and Matthew Lillard

Stu Macher ought to’ve come again as the brand new Ghostface. That is the hill I am prepared to die on following Scream (2022), the disappointingly Stu-less however nonetheless enjoyable “re-quel” from Prepared or Not co-administrators Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett. 

I do know what you are considering: “However Stu Macher is useless! Sidney Prescott dropped a TV on his head on the finish of Scream (1996), and he died.” To that I say: If Billy Loomis can return as a guiding ghost-dad, then there’s loads that’s honest sport in fashionable-day Woodsboro — and the reprisal of iconic co-conspirator Stu was properly inside attain.

How may Stu have survived his brush with dwelling-leisure head trauma? Effectively, within the closing faceoff between Sidney (Neve Campbell) and the 2 authentic Ghostfaces, Billy (Skeet Ulrich) succumbs to a rash of chest wounds earlier than being shot level-clean. The dying of his greatest bud, nevertheless, is rarely confirmed. 

It was only a TV? Proper? You’d assume he’d SURVIVE.


Sure, Stu (Matthew Lillard) suffers from a gnarly stabbing along with the aforementioned tv blow, full with electrocution. However because the fiercely humorous actor who performed him once tweeted, “It was only a TV? Proper? You’d assume he’d SURVIVE.”

Horror heavyweight and franchise creator Wes Craven reportedly had plans to reap the benefits of that chance in Scream 3 (2000), however a tortured manufacturing stored the story from taking place. Lillard revealed that behind-the-scenes tidbit via The Bob Bendick Podcast in 2010 (h/t Display screen Rant): “The concept was that from jail, [Stu] was masterminding this assault towards Sidney [and Woodsboro].”

Credit score: Paramount Photos

However three weeks earlier than filming was set to start out, the Columbine Excessive College shootings urged Scream 3’s makers to change instructions. As a substitute of returning to Woodsboro Excessive College, the primary Scream movie not written by Kevin Williamson would deal with the in-universe horror franchise Stab and a homicide spree in Hollywood.

“They modified every thing,” Lillard recalled for the podcast. “Took the script, threw it to the aspect, purchased me out, and I by no means did the third one.” 

Bringing Stu again to mentor a few crazed superfans is the kind of full-circle second ‘Scream 5’ wanted to actually stick the touchdown.

Figuring out this early-levels Stu sequel bought shelved, I used to be primed to see it lastly play out in Scream 5. And for roughly 90% of the film, I assumed I used to be proper. As a result of even in case you’re not watching to verify your personal Stu-centric suspicions, the character’s involvement is smart. For starters, the dude completely captures the poisonous fandom Scream 5’s screenwriters James Vanderbilt and Man Busick ship up within the closing act. 

Because it stands, newcomers Amber Freeman (Mikey Madison) and Richie Kirsch (Jack Quaid) clarify their motives for finishing up the Scream 5 slayings as an try to revitalize the Stab film franchise. By framing Billy Loomis’ daughter Sam Carpenter (Melissa Barrera) as the brand new killer and luring the “authentic” victims again to Woodsboro, the pair argue that they are serving to convey the upcoming Stab 9 “again to its roots.” They only love these films, and need to provide their writers recent but loyal “supply materials.”

Mikey Madison and Jack Quaid in 'Scream' (2021).

Credit score: Paramount Photos

It is a intelligent sufficient conceit that decently capitalizes on the forces that drove Stu and Billy to kill within the first movie (Scream 3 retconning however). Recall that within the authentic’s huge reveal scene, Stu frames his and Billy’s ascension into slasher villainy as an train in popular culture training: “Watch a couple of films, take a couple of notes…It was enjoyable!” Like Amber and Richie, Stu is a horror film nerd. That this famed serial killer would nonetheless be closely invested within the Stab franchise —  a zeitgeisty memorialization of his heinous crimes — checks out. 



31 important, historical past-making horror films to stream proper now

What’s extra, bringing Stu again to mentor a few crazed superfans is the kind of full-circle second Scream 5 wanted to actually stick the touchdown. Relying in your style for ghosts within the Scream universe, phantom Billy kind of will get us there with the entire “By no means fuck with a serial killer’s daughter” second from Sam. But it surely’s muddled by the truth that Billy is not a “good” man. His defending a daughter he could not have even recognized existed borders on illogical.

Stu, however, has solely a tenuous connection to Scream 5 by his nephew Vince Schneider (Kyle Gallner). So, he may have simply been repositioned because the film’s greatest unhealthy. Severely, simply think about it. Stu rising from behind a 3rd Ghostface masks — revealing not solely that he’d survived his combat with Sid again in 1996, however that the identical reign of terror he’d begun within the very first movie was nonetheless persevering with? The film’s physique rely would skyrocket; we might all be useless!

Matthew Lilliard in 'Scream' (1996)

Credit score: Paramount Photos

By lowering Stu to a footnote, Scream 5 fails to honor the lethal duo that kicked off this neatly scary story all of us love a lot. Nonetheless, I am holding out hope the powers that be will greenlight Scream 6 and give Stu his shot at revenge. Gale Weathers (Courteney Cox) might not be writing the Scream 5-primarily based ebook set to ignite one other era of Woodsboro suspects, however somebody ought to.

Plus, in case you go by Randy’s guidelines, we’re owed a second Stu sighting. The killer at all times comes again for one final scare — and Stu by no means bought his.

Scream (1996) is now streaming on Peacock; Scream (2022) is in theaters.

Show More

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button