Dining across the divide: ‘Don’t take this the wrong way, but people relate to the English differently’ | Life and style

Anne, 72, Argyll


Occupation Psychotherapist and author

Voting file Voted Labour when she was younger, but switched to Inexperienced some years in the past. Now votes Scottish Nationwide get together and Inexperienced


Amuse bouche Peter Sellers as soon as practically ran her over

Katie, 71, Argyll


Occupation Retired dentist

Voting file Has voted SNP and Inexperienced in the final three elections; beforehand voted Liberal Democrat. Means again in the darkish ages, voted Conservative. Has by no means voted Labour

Amuse bouche Cycles the Cowal peninsula each day; it’s “a correct cycle with correct hills”

For starters

Katie I’d taken a saltire face masks – I believed I’d meet somebody who didn’t imagine in Scottish independence.

Anne I’m Irish; I solely moved to Scotland as a result of my husband is Scottish.

Katie We each began with the cullen skink – a beautiful Scottish dish product of smoked haddock, cream and potatoes. Then I had the scallops.

Anne We had the identical starter, which was some sort of soup. Then I had the fishcakes and an elaborate dessert.

Katie and Anne

The massive beef

Katie We began speaking about immigration, and how vile the UK has grow to be; I’m shocked by the lack of compassion. Boris Johnson has seized on this narrative that appeals to a really small proportion of some nasty-minded people in England; it doesn’t have any resonance in Scotland.

Anne So I stated one thing a bit contentious. My father liked strolling alongside and saying hiya to his neighbours – he lived close to a women’ faculty, which was very enticing to Muslim households; extra and extra got here. He was this previous gentleman, strolling out and saying, “Good morning! Good morning!” and he used to say: “They by no means reply. And sometimes I’ve to step into the gutter. I don’t prefer it right here any extra.” I actually don’t like faith. It’s all the time tough when you might have fundamentalist Christianity or fundamentalist Islam, and then they encounter a liberal society. I believed Katie may not agree with me, but we have been genuinely concerned with what the different had to say. Each of us thought immigration had been blown out of proportion by sure media so as to keep away from coping with the true disaster of poverty.

Join to our Inside Saturday e-newsletter for an unique behind-the-scenes have a look at the making of the journal’s largest options, in addition to a curated record of our weekly highlights.

Katie Scotland has many issues, but they don’t seem to be xenophobia or racism – they’re extra sectarian. Anne was born and raised a Catholic, and I used to be born and raised Church of Scotland, so on that we must always have been diametrically opposed. But probably not, as a result of I don’t care about faith and nor does she.

Katie and Anne

Sharing plate

Katie I’m determined for Scotland to grow to be unbiased, so we will get away from the shambles that’s the UK. Don’t take this the wrong approach, but people relate to the English otherwise. In case you go anyplace in the world, you discover a a lot hotter welcome as a Scottish individual than a British one. It brings a smile to any person’s face – kilts, haggis, humorous tales. It cheers people. Being English doesn’t cheer anybody.

Anne I’m not fiercely pro-independence, as a result of I do know that there are complexities with the economics. Katie’s very Scottish and fiercely unbiased. I believe it could have come to blows if I had been in opposition to it. The place I’m coming from is Brexit, which was catastrophic – it simply smashed one thing for me. That’s why I’ll vote for independence.

Katie and Anne

For afters

Anne I shared that I had gone to an ayahuasca ceremony. My son had died and I couldn’t recover from it. I’d gone to this shaman and it actually helped me. I might inform that it wouldn’t have been one thing Katie would have accomplished, but she heard what I stated. She was current.

Katie The circumstances of her utilizing the shaman have been very particular – she was grieving over the demise of a beloved son. I’ve a son, and can not even start to think about how I might really feel in these circumstances. I imagine I might seize at something.

Katie and Anne


Anne The best way she listened, the approach we spoke – it was like assembly a comrade. I hope she felt the identical.

Katie Anne and I have been like soul sisters. I hope she meant it as a lot as I did, but I actually need to communicate. I’m usually a quiet, reserved individual, but I simply talked and talked and talked.

Katie and Anne

Extra reporting: Naomi Larsson

Anne and Katie ate at the Creggans Inn, Strachur, Argyll

Need to meet somebody from across the divide? Click on right here to discover out extra

Show More

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Back to top button