Delhi Muslims fear they will never see justice for religious riot atrocities | India

For a yr, Irfan has remained nearly completely in his home, too terrified to go away. A Muslim residing in north-east Delhi, he says that his highly effective Hindu neighbours, many belonging to the ruling Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata occasion (BJP), are maintaining a detailed watch on him. Jobless and afraid, he spoke in whispers of his fear of being “eradicated” at any time.

“I take a secure route to often depart my home to see my lawyer,” mentioned Irfan, who requested a pseudonym for safety. “I do know that BJP leaders and their followers are after me so I transfer round very fastidiously. I’ve to remain alive a minimum of to see those that attacked me are dropped at justice.”

It was one yr in the past final week that Irfan’s life as a easy Muslim shopkeeper was ripped aside: 23 February 2020, now often called the primary evening of the Delhi riots.

For 3 days, communal violence ripped by the north-east of India’s capital, the worst religious battle within the metropolis in 4 a long time. Although each Hindus and Muslims had been concerned within the violence, it was predominantly Muslims who fell sufferer to violent Hindu rightwing mobs roaming the neighbourhoods. A lot of these concerned had travelled from exterior Delhi and carried weapons, rods and explosives. Muslims had been overwhelmed, shot and lynched within the streets, 1000’s of their retailers and houses had been attacked and a minimum of 4 mosques had been left in charred ruins. Of the 53 who died within the violence, 40 had been Muslim.


Irfan is amongst these nonetheless combating for justice. He was sheltering in his store when a mob of round 150 individuals, together with lots of his Hindu neighbours, descended, throwing stones and armed with weapons and rods. Irfan alleges they had been led by a neighborhood BJP chief, who put a pistol to his head. He says the rioters shouted Hindu nationalist slogans and Muslim slurs as they looted his store after which set it on hearth with a petroleum bomb.

Irfan had been a member of the BJP for nearly a decade however, as a Muslim residing in a Hindu-majority space, it was not sufficient to guard him. Two days later, on 25 February, as neighbourhoods throughout north-east Delhi burned, the mob struck once more, focusing on his home, this time allegedly led partly by Mohan Singh Bisht, a neighborhood BJP politician who, Irfan says, threw a petroleum bomb at his home and led the mob with the cry: “Kill all katwa [kill all the circumcised Muslims].” A number of of Irfan’s neighbours confirmed this account to the Observer.

24 February 2020: men beat Mohammad Zubair, 37, a Muslim.
24 February 2020: males chanting pro-Hindu slogans beat Mohammad Zubair, 37, a Muslim. {Photograph}: Danish Siddiqui/Reuters

Bisht referred to as the allegations lies. “There isn’t any such case in opposition to me in any courtroom within the nation,” he mentioned. “I used to be not current in Delhi in the course of the riots. How may there be a case involving me within the violence?”

But within the yr that has handed, the police – who, Irfan alleges, had been complicit within the assaults – have repeatedly refused to register his case naming Bisht, different native BJP leaders and a few of his Hindu neighbours because the perpetrators.

Greater than 25 Muslims in his neighbourhood had been additionally allegedly denied the precise to file a case by police, regardless of claiming to know the identification of their attackers.

They took their instances to a lawyer, Mehmood Pracha, however Irfan is likely one of the few who has stored up the combat after native BJP figures and police allegedly threatened them with reprisals if they endured in taking the matter to courtroom. “I informed them on no situation would I withdraw,” mentioned Irfan.

Irfan’s case just isn’t an remoted one. Tons of of Muslim victims who’ve tried to file instances in opposition to their alleged Hindu attackers – who’ve typically been affiliated with the BJP – have spoken of being harassed and threatened by Delhi police who’ve refused to register their instances. In some situations, when victims went to police stations to identification and file their instances in opposition to rioters, the police as an alternative charged them or their relations with rioting.

Delhi police, a predominantly Hindu pressure, is below the remit of the federal government’s ministry of house affairs, led by Amit Shah, probably the most hardline Hindu nationalist ministers within the BJP authorities.

Of the practically 1,750 individuals arrested in reference to the riots, greater than half are Muslim, though disproportionate harm was carried out to their neighborhood. In cost sheets filed by Delhi police, nearly 70% identify Muslims because the perpetrators of assaults, even in instances when solely Muslims had been the victims. Delhi police didn’t reply to requests for remark.

Syed Zulfiqar, 34, a light-maker from Mohanpuri, was shot within the head on the 24 February when a neighborhood Hindu chief, whom he knew personally, fired at him in the course of the violence. “He pointed a gun at me and I heard him cry, ‘you’re a Muslim, we will kill you’, after which he fired the gun at me from a distance of about 20 metres,” mentioned Zulfiqar. “I nearly died. However once I went to the police station to register a case in opposition to this man, the police informed me they would solely settle for the report if I named my shooter as unidentified.” He alleges police then filed riot fees in opposition to his brother.

Mohammad Nasir Khan, 35, a authorities worker, who was shot within the eye and blinded when a mob of influential native Hindu males he knew fired at him, has nonetheless not been in a position to file his case. “I’ve tried so many instances nevertheless it has been one yr and the police nonetheless refuse,” mentioned Khan, wiping the gently weeping wound the place his eye as soon as was.

As a substitute, police filed their very own report on Khan’s case in June, naming a number of Muslims because the perpetrators of the assault and never mentioning the 4 native Hindus Khan alleged shot him.


Pracha is the lawyer representing many of those victims, but he has additionally discovered himself a goal and, in December, his workplace was raided by dozens of members of Delhi police particular cell on allegations of forgery.

“As a result of police’s proactive position in threatening, assaulting and intimidating the riot victims, only a few dare to open their mouths,” mentioned Pracha. “The police took some complaints from Muslim victims however solely on the situation that they wouldn’t identify any police officer or any BJP member,” mentioned Pracha.

Relatives mourning Hashim Ali, who died after being wounded during the riots.
Kinfolk mourn subsequent to the physique of Hashim Ali, who died after being wounded in the course of the riots. {Photograph}: Adnan Abidi/Reuters

“In lots of instances I’m dealing with, police have named Muslims because the accused the place they had been really the victims.”

In a number of bail hearings in opposition to accused Muslims, the police have failed to provide any proof. At a listening to last week, a choose granted bail to 3 Muslims accused of taking pictures one other Muslim, 25-year-old Shahid Alam, in the course of the riots on the premise it was “laborious to imagine” that Muslims would kill different Muslims in a communal riot.

Delhi police have additionally been accused of defending their very own officers from being charged. Tons of of eyewitnesses – in allegations verified by CCTV footage – accused police of each participating within the assaults on Muslims, permitting the Hindu mobs to focus on Muslims unimpeded and ignoring 1000’s of misery calls. Final yr, Amnesty International released a detailed report on the Delhi police’s position within the riots. However not a single officer has but been arrested or charged.

As a substitute, those that have felt the sturdy arm of the legislation for the reason that riots are those that say they had nothing to do with the violence in any respect.

After Shah, the house minister, informed parliament that the riots had been a “deep conspiracy”, Delhi police started a crackdown on anybody who had been concerned in peaceable anti-government protests within the months earlier than the riots.

Activists, lecturers, feminist collectives, college students and civilians – who had been described as “terrorists”, “traitors” and “jihadis” by authorities figures within the weeks earlier than the riots – have been charged with conspiring to fire up communal riots to be able to tarnish India’s repute, some below draconian terrorism legal guidelines.

Many have described this as a turning level within the BJP authorities’s crushing of democratic dissent. “The Delhi riots have been utilized by the police to go in spite of everything activists and anti-government protesters in Delhi within the identify of a false conspiracy that has no foundation in proof,” mentioned Nadeem Khan, co-founder of the activist group United In opposition to Hate, which has had a number of members arrested. “The entire of Delhi civil society resides in a state of fear.”

Notably absent from the Delhi police’s cost sheet are the names of many Hindu rioters and BJP leaders, particularly Kapil Mishra, the native BJP chief whose speech in north-east Delhi on 23 February, calling for his followers to clear the Muslim protesters and “educate them a lesson”, is broadly seen as sparking the riots.

Imam Mohammad Jalaluddin at al-Faruqi mosque, Delhi.
Mohammad Jalaluddin: after being overwhelmed nearly to dying final yr, the imam is simply too afraid to reside in Delhi now. {Photograph}: Shaikh Azizur Rahman

Mishra mentioned the police had completely investigated and cleared him. Echoing the Delhi police, he mentioned the riots had been a results of a “well-planned anti-national conspiracy by protesters to hijack the democracy of this nation and create the collapse of legislation and order”.

He denied information of the upper Muslim dying toll within the violence, however added: “Hitler died in world struggle two however can we name him a sufferer? Simply because that individual has died doesn’t imply they had been a sufferer. In any struggle or riot, extra individuals can die from one facet as a result of extra had been collaborating within the violence.”

Mishra mentioned he was working for communal concord in north-east Delhi however added: “My fear is that very deep-rooted hatred is being planted within the minds and hearts of the Muslim neighborhood by false propaganda.”

Within the neighbourhoods affected by the riots, the scars are nonetheless deep and visual. Dozens of homes sit vacant or locked up, spectral monuments to households who fled again to their villages exterior the capital, whereas neighbourhoods have turn into divided down communal strains.

Sitting within the not too long ago rebuilt al-Faruqi mosque within the suburb of Mustafabad, Imam Mohammad Jalaluddin carries a haunted look. He was overwhelmed nearly to dying by rioters who broke into the mosque and set it on hearth on 25 February. His jaw, smashed into three elements, is now constructed of metal plates and his face – ripped utterly in half – has been sewn again collectively. His fingers, constructed again along with metal pins, not bend correctly.

No fees have been introduced in opposition to Jalaluddin’s attackers. He and the mosque president, Mohammad Fakhruddin, allege it was law enforcement officials who led the violence, together with firing tear gasoline into the mosque and beating the imams. It was additionally allegedly law enforcement officials who returned the subsequent morning to destroy the CCTV proof.

“I discover it very laborious being on this mosque and typically I get flashbacks to what occurred to me and I begin shaking and break into tears,” Jalaluddin mentioned softly.

“Subsequent week, I will return to my village in Bihar and reside there,” he added. “I studied in a madrasa right here since I used to be 10 and later turned an imam. I cherished this metropolis. However after the violence that left me nearly lifeless –and I’ve survived by the grace of Allah – I’m too afraid to reside right here any longer.”

Show More

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Back to top button