António Guterres’ role questioned in UN harassment case – POLITICO

210520 antonio guterres gty 773

Press play to hearken to this text

It was simply 5 days after Fabrizio Hochschild Drummond gained a serious appointment to be the United Nations’ first know-how envoy that he was positioned on paid depart, pending an investigation into office harassment allegations in opposition to him.

U.N. Secretary-Common António Guterres stated by way of his spokesperson that the primary he discovered of the allegations was after he had already awarded Hochschild his promotion.

However it wasn’t the primary that his personal workers knew of the allegations in opposition to Hochschild. 

A POLITICO investigation into the case reveals that not less than one member of Guterres’ senior workers was conscious that formal complaints have been about to be lodged in opposition to Hochschild by certainly one of his former feminine subordinates — greater than a month earlier than his promotion occurred.

In an e mail reviewed by POLITICO, the previous Hochschild workers member sought recommendation from a member of Guterres’ chef de cupboard’s workplace about how one can proceed together with her criticism.

That criticism sheds gentle on the circumstances main as much as the investigation into Hochschild over allegations of discrimination, harassment, sexual harassment and abuse of authority, in line with paperwork reviewed by POLITICO.

The inquiry into Hochschild was first reported when he was suspended on January 27. POLITICO’s reporting, which incorporates intensive interviews with 5 present and former U.N. workers members, shines a light-weight on the motivations of ladies who complained about him.

In tales from completely different sources that always overlap, these ladies described feeling bullied by abusive language, demanding phone calls at late-night hours and weekends, and feedback from Hochschild saying his workplace didn’t need ladies workers to get pregnant. POLITICO has the accounts of some complainants however doesn’t have entry to different proof, whether or not corroborating or exculpatory, that might be out there to the investigators.

In emails, Hochschild denied the allegations, however declined to remark additional whereas the inquiry is underway. He referred to as the allegations “unfounded.”

POLITICO’s reporting, in the meantime, highlights a brand new query: Why did Guterres proceed with the promotion when some on his workers had a preview of the difficulty that lay simply forward?

The present and former U.N. workers say they imagine they know the reply. High ranges of the U.N., they stated, have a tradition of favoritism in which influential insiders like Hochschild advance simply and get the good thing about the doubt, whereas individuals elevating questions on improper office conduct aren’t listened to as significantly as they need to be.

In 2019, one in three U.N. workers and contractors stated that they had been sexually harassed in the previous two years, in line with a U.N. study.

By a spokesman, Guterres stated he does take the difficulty significantly, and that he acted instantly to place Hochschild on depart till the questions on his conduct have been resolved.

However the present and former workers — who all spoke on situation of anonymity, citing considerations about retaliation — stated the time to take motion had handed.

“That is the stuff that undermines belief,” stated one of many staffers who beforehand labored below Hochschild and has now left the U.N. “These are the problems which are essential, finally, as a result of they’re so inside his [Guterres’] energy.”

‘Poisonous office’

Hochschild’s three-decade profession contained in the U.N. adopted a trajectory typical of staffers who make their reputations on high-risk assignments all over the world.

Hochschild’s standing in the U.N. as an under-secretary-general is analogous to that of a authorities minister. He started his profession in 1988 working for the United Nations Excessive Commissioner for Refugees in Sudan, and in the years since has labored as a U.N. peacekeeper and at varied U.N. businesses, together with the United Nations Growth Programme in Colombia and the Workplace of the Excessive Commissioner for Human Rights in Geneva.

Earlier than being promoted to his most up-to-date job, as coordinator for the U.N.’s seventy fifth anniversary commemorations, Hochschild labored carefully with Guterres as assistant secretary-general for strategic coordination on the thirty eighth flooring of the U.N.’s New York Metropolis headquarters — the identical flooring from which Secretary-Common Guterres works. The U.N.’s announcement of his promotion to the tech role cited his “diversified senior management expertise, each at Headquarters and in the sphere.”

In response to one U.N. worker who has labored with Hochschild in the previous yr, Hochschild’s document in battle zones made him an “archetypal ‘hero’ in the U.N.”

Having been by way of “horrible stuff” had given him a “free move” in the group, added the worker. A number of of the U.N. insiders stated the establishment coated problematic conduct on account of a macho tradition that persists contained in the establishment regardless of public rhetoric about gender equality and inclusion.

In Hochschild’s case, they stated this meant being promoted regardless of complaints that he created a poisonous office in his job coordinating U.N. seventy fifth anniversary commemorations, often known as UN75, in line with the 5 present and former workers, who labored below him throughout 2019 and 2020.

Considered one of them, who described Hochschild’s administration fashion as “demoralizing,” recalled receiving texts and emails from him at midnight and on holidays for pressing work. “He referred to as my work ineffective. He instructed individuals their work was trash,” the ex-employee stated, including that that they had been anticipated to work whereas identified with COVID-19. Individuals who labored with Hochschild stated he was meticulous about conducting aggressive conversations over the telephone and by no means in writing.

Two former subordinates stated Hochschild would typically joke about ladies not being allowed to get pregnant or married in his workplace. Considered one of his feminine workers members was instructed that her contract wouldn’t be renewed days after she introduced she was pregnant, endangering her entry to well being care and immigration standing. The authorized dispute round her contract ended when she was provided a brand new role elsewhere in the group.

Hochshild’s three former subordinates filed their complaints in December 2020 and early January 2021. The U.N.’s Workplace of Inner Oversight Providers (OIOS) launched an investigation, and interviews have been performed with the complainants in early and mid-January, in line with individuals with information of the investigation. 

Then, on January 22, in a transfer that caught many U.N. diplomats off-guard, Guterres introduced that he had appointed Hochschild because the U.N.’s first-ever tech envoy. On January 27, Hochschild was positioned on depart over the investigation.

But a former staffer who wished to file an official criticism about Hochschild had contacted a member of Guterres’ chef de cupboard’s workplace on December 11 for recommendation, in line with the e-mail seen by POLITICO.

“Of late too many individuals working below USG [Under-Secretary-General] Hochschild are reaching out to me searching for help on how one can cope. This triggered some guilt for me that I ought to have carried out extra final yr,” the e-mail learn.

The Guterres aide had replied supplying the identify of a contact in the Workplace of Authorized Employees Help, the U.N.’s inside justice system.

“I recall from our dialog that I had indicated there are avenues to workers members searching for recommendation or help,” the member of Guterres’ chef de cupboard’s workplace wrote in the e-mail.

Requested whether or not the secretary-general had been knowledgeable concerning the complaints, his workplace stated he solely discovered on January 27 after which triggered an investigation.

Lobbying blitz

To many who had been following the tech envoy course of, Hochschild’s nomination got here as a shock.

A self-described “newcomer” to the tech portfolio, the Chilean-British diplomat beat a number of high-profile, tech-savvy candidates who had been nominated by their member international locations. These included former Estonian President Toomas Hendrik Ilves, Finnish member of the European Parliament Miapetra Kumpula-Natri, India’s Amandeep Singh Gill, who ran the U.N.’s Excessive-Degree Panel on Digital Cooperation, and Dutch politician Marietje Schaake, who’s at the moment worldwide coverage director at Stanford’s Cyber Coverage Middle.

None of those candidates have been interviewed, in line with two former workers members and three U.N. diplomats. 

A number of diplomats stated that that they had anticipated a proper course of and an extended timeline for appointing the envoy provided that inside discussions about creating the role had began years earlier, they stated. The Europeans have been notably irritated as they’re attempting to place themselves as leaders in the worldwide tech dialog and had seen the place as a chance.

A lot of the frustration round Hochschild’s nomination targeted on his fundraising for the brand new role. In contrast to different U.N. positions, funding for the tech envoy’s work doesn’t come from the establishment’s general price range, however solely from member nation donations.

The proposal for the creation of a tech envoy got here out of the U.N.’s high-level panel and roadmap on digital cooperation. The tech envoy is charged with implementing the secretary-general’s digital agenda, targeted on constructing connectivity and worldwide cooperation.

Work on the U.N.’s tech initiatives was funded by Switzerland, China, the United Arab Emirates, Norway, Qatar, Denmark, Finland, Denmark, the U.Ok., Germany and Israel, in addition to foundations such because the Invoice and Melinda Gates Basis and the Alibaba Basis. However more cash was wanted for the tech envoy’s workplace.

In a challenge proposal despatched to member international locations for fundraising functions, seen by POLITICO and dated July 2020, the tech envoy’s workplace was projected to want a complete price range of $3,280,574.

Hochschild set about elevating that cash and lobbying U.N. member international locations personally for the creation of the role, in line with his former staffers. Cash from the UN75 price range was used through the second half of 2020 to fund the salaries of workers working to create the tech envoy’s workplace, in line with the challenge proposal seen by POLITICO.

“It felt a bit bit egregious in the sense that for the previous few years, what he is carried out is helped create this place for himself to occupy, as a result of all of us knew that after the commemoration of the seventy fifth anniversary, it wasn’t clear if this gentleman had a job in the U.N. system,” stated a U.N. diplomat based mostly in Geneva.

The know-how envoy’s month-to-month charge is marked as $35,117 (€28,715), or $421,404 (€344,588) a yr — greater than double the gross annual base salary of an under-secretary-general, which was $200,998 in 2020. By comparability, the U.S. president makes $33,333 (€27,259) a month or $400,000 (€327,120) a yr.

Civil society teams, led by digital rights group Entry Now, despatched an open letter in October 2020 asking for transparency in the tech envoy’s choice course of. “We did not hear something again,” stated Laura O’Brien, the group’s U.N. advocacy officer.

In Hochschild’s absence, his workplace has been run by Maria-Francesca Spatolisano, the assistant secretary-general for coverage coordination and inter-agency affairs on the division of financial and social affairs, in addition to senior program officer Yu Ping Chan.

“The workplace is constant to mobilize funding for its work,” a U.N. spokesperson stated. “The present price range covers the work by way of 31 December 2021.”

A deep-rooted drawback

Critics argue Hochschild’s case is way from remoted.

Whereas the U.N. claims to have a zero-tolerance method, in 2019 one in three U.N. workers and contractors stated that they had been sexually harassed in the previous two years, in line with a U.N. study.

In response to the U.N.’s latest statistics, in 2020 the group obtained 66 allegations of sexual exploitation and abuse in peacekeeping and 91 allegations about U.N. personnel outdoors peacekeeping. The variety of circumstances has stayed regular in latest years.

Purna Sen, who was in cost of addressing office harassment at U.N. Ladies, told the Guardian in December 2020 that she feared the group’s efforts to sort out sexual harassment have been “placed on the again burner.” 

“The system lacks independence and there’s a actual drawback with accounts being taken significantly. Managers are instructed to begin with the presumption of innocence however this has translated to a beginning place of mistrust of these making complaints,” she stated. 

In its newest report on stopping sexual exploitation, the U.N. stated it would launch a digitized complaints platform and replace its “sexual exploitation and abuse e-learning programme” for employees.

Two former workers members described collaborating in a dignity and harassment coaching session led by Hochschild. “It felt tense, as a lot as you possibly can really feel rigidity on Microsoft Groups calls,” the previous staffer stated.

The U.N. spokesperson underscored ongoing efforts to fight harassment. Guterres “strengthened the U.N.’s investigating and we now have a specialised group of investigators, principally ladies, who’re targeted solely on wanting into allegations of sexual harassment,” the spokesperson stated.

The U.N. has a helpline for staffers to report sexual harassment, and has additionally adopted a database that ought to stop individuals who have been let go due to harassment points by one U.N. company to be employed by one other. However workers members say these processes usually are not sufficient as a result of many victims worry retaliation, and allegations take months if not years to resolve.

“It is not possible to truly maintain individuals to account in follow, except you actually stick your neck out,” the previous staffer stated. “And most of the people I do know who desire a job in the system simply would not do this.”

Ryan Heath contributed reporting.

This text is a part of POLITICO’s premium Tech coverage protection: Professional Know-how. Our skilled journalism and suite of coverage intelligence instruments can help you seamlessly search, monitor and perceive the developments and stakeholders shaping EU Tech coverage and driving choices impacting your business. Electronic mail [email protected] with the code ‘TECH’ for a complimentary trial.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button