Analyzing Kellen Moore and Mike McCarthy’s controversial QB draw call

classybuzzJanuary 18, 2022

17 9 minutes read

Tons to wash up from wild-card weekend, let’s dive in …

• Let’s begin with the Cowboys and the quarterback draw call that’ll go down in infamy—one authored by Kellen Moore and licensed by Mike McCarthy, who defended it after the sport because the “proper call.” I’ve run this up the flagpole with just a few coaches right now. There are some things that I really feel comfy saying. One, if you happen to get the ball clocked, just like the Cowboys did, and you’re pushing the ball down the center of the sphere, both on the bottom or by the air, you’ll want a minimum of 16 seconds, and some groups set their guidelines at 18 seconds, to get ball clocked once more.

“At 14, you’re taking part in Russian roulette,” stated one veteran offensive coach. Two, Dak Prescott and middle Tyler Biadasz ought to be coached in that scenario to right away, upon the earlier play’s ending, get the ball to the umpire, as a result of he’s the one who must set it earlier than it may be snapped once more. And three, some groups in that spot may have a play in-built that they’ll snap the ball to, if there isn’t sufficient time to clock it. So how’d the Cowboys do? They known as the draw with 14 seconds left. Prescott and Biadasz tried to set and snap the ball on their very own, really blocking the umpire from setting it as they did it. And the official gamebook reveals that Prescott really did get the snap off, which means he might’ve thrown it into the tip zone and the play would’ve counted. Within the grand scheme of issues, this may increasingly seem to be small stuff. However NFL video games, and particularly playoff video games, are often received on the margins—which means situational play (purple zone, third down, and many others., and many others.) is usually the distinction between successful and dropping. It certain was in Arlington on Sunday afternoon.

Advertisements

• Whereas we’re there, there was really one other scenario that flew below the radar over the weekend that wasn’t fairly as unhealthy, however nonetheless merited scrutiny. There was an previous soccer coach named Homer Smith who had a saying about two-minute soccer—“You both run out of time otherwise you run out of downs.” The purpose of the adage was, primarily, that coaches ought to do their greatest to protect each as greatest they’ll. The Raiders didn’t do this in essentially the most vital spot on Saturday. With 45 seconds left, Derek Carr snapped the ball into third-and-10 on the 19, down 26–19, and hit Zay Jones on the sticks to arrange first-and-goal from the 9. He and the offense hurried to the road and spiked it with 30 seconds left, giving them three snaps to attain from 9 yards out—a difficult scenario the place it’s a must to throw the ball in a condensed space.

Wouldn’t the Raiders have been higher off giving themselves 4 pictures? A narrative I heard Monday really defined how Alabama coach Nick Saban handles these conditions. He has one-word play calls in-built that work whatever the personnel grouping on the sphere, so regardless of who’s on the market, the workforce can hustle to line and get that additional shot on the finish zone. The quarterback’s instructed to watch out for issues wanting off, as a result of it is a hurry-up scenario, nevertheless it’s on the very least a manner a workforce can use all 4 downs in a spot like that, with the worst-case state of affairs in the best way it’s coached (an incompletion) being the identical because the spike. As a substitute of doing it this manner, in fact, Las Vegas solely compelled Cincinnati to make three stops, and the Bengals did, in order that they’re transferring on.

• Talking of the Raiders, I can perceive why the workforce would wish to clear the decks and begin anew after the best way 2021 went. However the dealing with of the Mike Mayock scenario was weird. Mayock’s scouting division spent Monday working by free company and faculty all-star sport assignments, solely to see on social media within the afternoon that the Raiders had submitted a request for Patriots exec Dave Ziegler to interview for a GM spot that they didn’t know was open. Clearly, the NFL’s a chilly enterprise. And the writing’s been on the wall with Mayock for some time—he didn’t all the time see eye to eye with ex-coach Jon Gruden, and rumors flew final spring that he could possibly be fired after the draft. It didn’t occur then. It has occurred now. However that it went down this manner, to me, is simply unhealthy enterprise on the a part of the Raiders.

• Twelve or so years in the past, Patriots coach Invoice Belichick, then in his late 50s, advised an NFL Movies crew taking pictures his A Soccer Life documentary, “I received’t be like Marv Levy teaching in my 70s, I do know that.” On Monday, at his season-ending press convention, Belichick advised reporters that he does, in actual fact, plan to teach in 2022. “I might say that’s correct,” he stated. And that ensures that he’ll, in actual fact, coach into his 70s—he hits the large quantity on April 16. To be clear, the thought right here is not to call Belichick out on having stated one thing greater than a decade in the past that he’s now going again on. Belichick himself, in actual fact, stated just a few years again on Boston radio that his feeling on teaching at that age had modified.

The rationale we’re bringing it up? To look at why he retains going. And I truthfully consider the reply is so simple as it’s been for Belichick’s previous quarterback, Tom Brady. He nonetheless loves it, and there isn’t something he’d relatively do. And there are, certainly, some issues which have modified. One, being in a single NFL location for so long as he has been doesn’t make it turnkey—no professional soccer group works fairly that manner—nevertheless it does make a spot extra self-sustaining. Merely put, Belichick doesn’t have the identical mountain of points {that a} man in his first yr, or fifth yr, and even tenth yr in a spot would possibly. Two, due to developments in know-how, it’s simpler to do sure elements of the job remotely, making it simpler for a man like Belichick to do issues individuals of their golden years would wish to, whereas nonetheless doing his job. Three, his children are grown and working for him now, so going to the workplace additionally occurs to be household time. Belichick’s fond of claiming teaching soccer “beats working” and I actually consider he feels that manner about. And so long as he can do the job the best way he’s now, I feel it’ll be a short while earlier than he walks away.

Mike McCarthy (Tim Heitman/USA TODAY Sports activities), Invoice Belichick (Wealthy Barnes/USA TODAY Sports activities), Deebo Samuel (Tim Heitman/USA TODAY Sports activities)

• If you happen to’ve learn my stuff the previous couple of months, you understand I’ve this idea—that there are receivers coming into the league now who, 20 years in the past, due to economics and the construction of right now’s sport vs. yesterday’s, would’ve been working backs. And I feel good coaches are realizing that with a few of them, and turning them into Percy Harvin–model hybrids. The perfect such case? Niners star Deebo Samuel, who’s mainly develop into a part-time tailback, along with what he brings the offense as a receiver. And so I figured I’d ask Kyle Shanahan if that’s the best way the Niners noticed Samuel all alongside, going again to taking him within the second spherical in 2019

“In faculty, he regarded like he had working again abilities, simply when he would catch a display screen or something—simply how he ran and how bodily he was,” Shanahan advised me. “In order that makes you sort of get concepts and wish to use them in sure methods. However you by no means understand how a man’s gonna be as a working again till you watch them. And we gave Deebo a bunch, even proper when he acquired right here, as a rookie, simply extra outdoors stuff and extra your typical receiver-type issues making an attempt to get across the edge. However once we began him versus the Rams earlier this yr, we gave him some extra inside-zone and some tighter issues, and he was all the time hitting the best gap and going, and you simply begin to see his pure abilities at it. That he’s not only a specimen when it comes to his dimension and velocity, however he’s additionally very expert at it—it’s not too huge a deal for him. And it makes it a hell of lots simpler for us to get him the ball. That’s what I like essentially the most.”

An enormous piece of that is that Samuel’s constructed for it, at 6′ 0”, 216 kilos. And because it’s labored so effectively, it’d hardly be stunning to see, a yr from now perhaps, different groups which have receivers constructed that manner making an attempt a few of this.

• Clearly, a workforce getting its first playoff win in three many years goes to be an enormous deal for the fan base and the franchise itself. And Zac Taylor and his coaches actually honored that on Saturday evening. However Taylor advised me it was abundantly clear to him on the workforce’s Sunday morning assembly that the gamers had already moved on to the divisional spherical—principally as a result of the gamers’ mentality all alongside has been to count on that sort of progress. Which actually is why they have been in a position to deal with all that Saturday meant to Cincinnati the best way they did in beating the Raiders within the first place.

“Actually, I by no means felt that from the workforce, that they felt the stress from the final 31 years,” Taylor advised me. “Perhaps if we’d misplaced that sport and you needed to undergo an offseason of listening to that and going by subsequent season, that stress might have constructed for these guys. But it surely didn’t this time round. And so it’s not gonna matter once more. It’s over. I’m glad that everybody is ready to put that behind them and now we are able to simply deal with transferring ahead.”

• Dropping Larry Ogunjobi for the playoffs is a blow for the Bengals, and simply dropping him for the Raiders sport was a blow on Saturday evening. In actual fact, as a result of they’d misplaced Ogunjobi, Mike Daniels and Trey Hendrickson in-game, as defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo defined it to me, Cincinnati actually wouldn’t have been in a position to get into its goal-line personnel on the finish of the sport. Fortunately, as a result of the Raiders have been taking part in from behind, and as a result of the clock was ticking, it actually by no means got here into play for Cincinnati. However, actually, defensive position depth is one thing to maintain a watch now for the Bengals, with a visit to play the uber-physical Titans on faucet.